But series creator Jeff Davis sure as hell didn't when asked who he'd revive during a talk at Comic-Con.
"That's easy. Jennifer. I freely admit it was a mistake to kill her off. Also, because Hayley [Webb] is such a good person and she's one of those people you want to bring back to set because you enjoy having her there. Such good energy!"
He is, of course, referring to Ms. Blake, the English teacher who got trapped in the school basement and was later rescued by Derek and became his love interest in season three.
But unforch it was revealed that she was actually Darach, the creature who slaughtered Beacon Hills High School students and therefore she was ultimately killed off.
So maybe this one was for the best?
We sure as heck haven't missed her!