While the Pretty Little Liars star sat down with her co-stars for Ellen DeGeneres' YouTube show Show Me More and played "Never Have I Ever," all was revealed.
When they were asked if any of the girls had ever made an assistant cry, they ALL said never - except Shay.
"Yeah! I mean in a good way, but a good cry. Everybody needs a good cry," she said. "In a good way. Cries of like, happiness," Shay said, looking sheepish.
Troian pushed for more though, asking her, "You made her cry with tears of sheer joy?" To which you can hear Shay's assistant say off camera, "It was not."
Shay then joked, "Do you want a job still?"
If you follow Shay on social media, you'll know that her assistant, Sammy Rosenman, is also her best friend. So it's all in good humour.
Sammy was the one who posted the video on her Instagram, with the caption, "This video finally surfaced from when the girls did @theellenshow and I love it 🙌🏻😭 #itwasnot."