Instead, she gave him up for adoption.
With that handful of information, the internet has done what it does best and made an insane theory.
They added that the theory about FP Jones (Jughead's father) being the real dad fits into this, as it also explains his and Alice's weird history.
The actor who plays Joaquin, Rob Raco has actually hinted to this theory on Twitter, writing "FP + Alice - who...? #Riverdale."
"J: 'I'm actually your son too.' FP: '...' #Riverdale."
WELL OKAY THEN!!
Guess we will have to wait for October when season two is released to find out the truth!!