Fans are convinced that he was in her 2011 music video "Love You Like a Love Song!"
Seventeen sat down with Timothy and asked him straight.
“Nah, that guy in the mariachi band playing the futuristic flute wearing Donatello’s purple eye mask who looks just like me isn’t me… definitely not me,” he joked.
Tim added, “But if you look closely, it’s me.”
IS IT?! ISN'T IT?
We honestly don't know.