Dutch singer Elieve, who ironically has been compared to Camila in the past (she even covered her song "Sangria Wine") made the confession that she was actually dating Matthew at the same time Camila was.
Speaking during a Dutch radio show, Elieve explained that, "Camila and I were both dating the same guy at the same time. […] It happened in London when I was working on the singles. I met him and he was actually really great…a really smart guy, handsome. I guess it was just too good to be true. So when I came back from London I saw the paparazzi pics in Mexico with Camila. Isn’t it insane? I just hope they are happy and wish them the best."
The radio host asked her if Camila and Matthew "were already in a relationship" when she started dating him, and she responded with: "I think he was dating us at the same time and when the pictures came out he couldn’t deny it any longer," she said.
"When we were together we talked about the fact that I kind of look like [her] and he responded with, 'She’s quite a fan of me.' I said, 'Oh, really?' and he told me that he met her on Good Morning America. Well, I guess it was more than just fangirling."
Elieve is no longer in contact with Matthew, because she "didn't like the way he handed" the whole situation, but she isn't bitter towards him or Camila.
Camilizers on the other hand, want his head.
Of course, right now it's all hearsay, so we wonder if Camila or Matthew will make any comments on the matter...