The feuding began when they started to discuss Mikey's alleged affair with bride Stacey Hampton.
"It was four hours after we broke up. We were well over before I slept with Stacey," Mikey said before Natasha added: "No we weren't. You asked me for dinner that night. That's not true. You're lying."
"I don't want to speak to you," he said with hatred in his voice. "I am not worried about what people think. I could bring up 65 rumours on what Natasha did during our marriage."
"I had your back, Mikey," Natasha yelled. "I called you the day after I had read those text messages between you and Stacey. You said she tried to come to you but it was you who went to her," she said, referring to Mikey and Stacey's coffee date which came after rumours began swirling he'd cheated on his TV wife.
Things took a turn for the worse when the questions centred on their honeymoon, and the weird questions Mikey asked her at the time. Moments after she opened up about her cervical cancer battle, he asked if he could contract it and "pass it on to the next girl he slept with".
"She spoke to the Daily Mail and said all these lies about what happened during our honeymoon. I thought cervical cancer was a strain of HPV. I was confused, that was just a sexual health question. I am a male, how am I supposed to know these things? I don't have a cervix."
"I'm shaking," said a defeated Natasha who was clearly fed up with going around in circles. "He knows what he asked me. STI testing is compulsory before entering the experiment so I am sure Mikey knew I didn't have HPV. I think there is a better question and way of asking whether he could pass it on to the next girl."
"I am sick of talking to her. I wish you all the best Natasha but you get on my nerves. The amount of shit you talk... Uh," he said before groaning.
After their explosive interview ended— leaving the pair on extremely bad terms— a beaten-down Natasha opened up about her tumultuous time on the dating series, admitting the pressure got to her and she spiralled out of control.
"I left the show because I had a breakdown. I had to leave for my mental health which is something that's never happened before. After I met Mikey's parents, I had a panic attack in my toilet. I was so tired," she said through tears. "After that, I just shut down. I decided it wasn't good for me to be on the show. I didn't see that coming."