Well it turns out you can.
Elle reports that Sel's assistant Theresa Mingus was spotted on Thursday picking up the exact same Cavalier King Charles Spaniel puppy that Selena was cuddling.
Theresa was later seen delivering the puppy to her apartment.
A fan account on Twitter also posted pics from the pet store, in which a sign read, "I'm going HOME soon!" on the dog's kennel.
So what's the problem?
Fans were disappointed that Selena chose to purchase the dog from a pet store, (because many are known for selling puppies raised in unethical puppy mills), rather than adopting one from a shelter.
"Why BUY instead of adopting this makes me so mad," one Twitter user wrote.
Another fan on Instagram wrote, "I also can't believe you would buy a puppy from the pet stores that are breeding and putting animals in glass and have them in bad living situations. Don't support stuff like that girl. Thought you knew better."
Selena has rescued five shelter dogs since of 2010, according to People, so fans are now thinking this new pupper will be co-owned by her and The Weeknd.