Honestly, same though.
So which member got Puth's attention???
None other than Jade Thirlwall. Of course, she couldn't be more his type TBH.
During Charlie's chat with Dan Wootton on the Bizarre Life podcast, he admitted that: "Me and Jade had a bit of a look on X Factor. She’s in a relationship I found out that night. I was on stage singing with them and was like, 'Oh jade, she’s so sexy.' She’s so lovely, [but] well she’s taken. I will say she’s taken and I’m glad she’s happy," Charlie said.
Watch their performance below: